(Vienna, 12 November 2019) Scientists at the Complexity Science Hub Vienna (CSH) and the Medical University of Vienna (MedUni Vienna) have developed a stress test to determine the resilience of regional health care in real time. They used a 1:1 computer model of the Austrian primary health care system in the form of patient flows in regional physician networks as a basis. The innovative model provides concrete answers to questions such as: How important is a certain doctor for the functioning of primary care in my region? How many and which doctors’ retirements can the system absorb? At what point can primary health care no longer be guaranteed for everyone in a region? The paper appears in the latest issue of the journal PNAS.
How safe is the primary health care system?
Usually, the number of physicians in relation to the population—the so-called physician density—is used as an indicator for the quality of health care. Yet, this indicator assumes that all physicians are equally accessible and equally important for all patients. "We show that this is not the case,” says Peter Klimek from CSH and MedUni Vienna. “Physicians and their patients form networks. With the same physician density, these networks can either be resilient or prone to collapse, or something in between,” Klimek points out.
The complexity researchers used a research data set including all Austrian physicians and patient streams from 2006/2007 to create the network. Resident physicians are the nodes, connected to each other by their patients. "We were surprised at how closely connected and regionally focused the networks of patient flows are," mentions Klimek. The researchers called this “patient sharing.”
This point becomes relevant as soon as a doctor's office closes. The data show that more than 80 percent of all patients choose physicians for their further medical care with whom they have previously had contact. Knowing that, the researchers are able to calculate with high accuracy where patients of a particular doctor will turn after the doctor’s retirement.
Simulation makes patient flows visible
An interactive simulation, programmed by Johannes Sorger (CSH), illustrates the network dynamics. In the simulation, natural persons were replaced 1:1 by anonymous avatars. "We can click away single doctor avatars and observe where their patients are moving on to," explains Peter Klimek (see link below).
A resilient health care system will recover quickly and fully from such shocks. However, the loss of too many doctors at a time or of particularly important doctors can overstrain the system. "The simulation shows the critical point at which the system's ability to absorb additional patients or compensate for lost doctors collapses," states the first author of the publication, Donald Ruggiero Lo Sardo (CSH, MedUni Vienna). "Thanks to our model, we know how many and which doctors can be removed from the system without problems," he adds. "We can say how resilient the health care system is in a certain region. And we can determine how relevant each avatar is to the stability of the regional network."
For example, doctors with particularly large numbers of patients and good accessibility within the doctors' network lend stability to the system. Poorly networked doctors, on the other hand, will more likely weaken the system.
A model for many areas
The model provides stakeholders in the health care sector with a tool that allows (personnel) decisions and their effects to be tested in advance.
The researchers emphasize that the new method can be extended to diverse scenarios, such as the outbreak of an epidemic or a natural disaster with many casualties. "With up-to-date data, we can make valid assertions about the resilience of different sub-systems in health care," maintains Klimek. This knowledge facilitates planning and improves medical care. "As soon as people in charge know the systemically relevant doctors in a region, they can make the health care system more resilient by either trying to retain those doctors or to adequately refill their positions after their leave," Klimek concludes.
An interactive simulation of the doctors' network in the Austrian province of Vorarlberg (anonymized) can be accessed online at https://csh.ac.at/vis/med_public/pcn-resilience
Donald Ruggiero Lo Sardo, Stefan Thurner, Johannes Sorger, Georg Duftschmid, Gottfried Endel, Peter Klimek, Quantification of the resilience of primary care networks by stress-testing the health-care system, PNAS November 11 (2019) www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1904826116
About the Complexity Science Hub Vienna
The CSH Vienna is a joint initiative of the Medical University of Vienna, the TU Wien, the Vienna University of Economics and Business, the Graz University of Technology, the Danube University Krems, the IIASA International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, the AIT Austrian Institute of Technology, and the Austrian Economic Chambers (WKO).
The mission of the Hub is to host, educate, and inspire complex systems scientists who are dedicated to collecting, handling, aggregating, and making sense of Big Data in ways that are directly valuable for science and society. Scientists at the Hub develop methods for the scientific, quantitative, and predictive understanding of complex systems. Focal areas include the resilience and efficiency of socio-economic and ecological systems, network medicine, the dynamics of innovation, and the science of cities. www.csh.ac.at